Ecological Sustainability
To what extent our websites are sustainable? So that means e.g. reduction of file sizes, green web hosting, other measures of green web engineering or similar? Is Autonomic somehow sustainable in their work, climate neutral or similar? And what about Hetzner, who are hosting the website?
If this question is very important for documenta, they could fund : https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/
If this is in any way about marketing and communication they should refrain completely from making any statements about the ecological sustainability of lumbung.space. Information Technology is just not ecologically sustainable, period.
Every data center claims to be green and what not, but at the bottom line there is not enough renewables to go around. It is all greenwashing and accounting tricks, buying certificates, offsets and what not. For example lumbung.space is hosted by hetzner in finland which has these things to say: https://www.hetzner.com/unternehmen/umweltschutz/
If this is not about marketing but certificates and compliance etc, they can point at hetzner's certificate and play good news :)
This is complex subject, and it will take research to give a serious answer, but we can say a couple of things:
The hosting provider we use runs on 100% renewable energy, according to their website, and according to the Green Web Foundation's Green Web Check - a tool which was recommended to us by another non-profit. However, it is also worth keeping in mind that many hosting providers - including Google Cloud - make similar claims to play down the massive energy cost of running internet services at scale.
lumbung.space is a statically generated site. These kinds of sites typically consume much less computing resources than dynamic websites, which make up a large portion of the web. WordPress sites (which make up 53% of websites on the internet), are one example of a non-statically generated site.
However, this doesn't take into account other parts of the lumbung.space ecosystem, such as nongkrong.lumbung.space (which lumbung working groups use to chat), tv.lumbung.space, social.lumbung.space, et cetera, which are all dynamic web applications. Assessing the ecological impact of these sites/services vis-a-vis alternatives which provide similar functionality, like YouTube, Twitter, Google Drive, Vimeo, Dropbox, or even other open source solutions, is a complicated endeavor and we are not sure we can give a conclusive answer in a short amount of time. In fact, I think answering this question could be a research project on its own.